Ben Castoriano got booted without even so much as a fighting chance. The reason wouldn’t have stood in court for being based on pure hearsay, but “love” (or reality TV) and law are two different galaxies. Rival William Holman played the sneak by offering dubious information to Ashley Hebert to gain edge during their 2-on-1 date. He had overheard Castoriano joking around with some of the other guys about going to online dating sites after the show. He intentionally misunderstood the locker room-type banter as serious talk and told on Castoriano. Hebert took the information to heart and sent Castoriano packing. Castoriano thinks this was the right call ultimately anyway.